Sartini Dentistry logo
Mon - Thur
8:00 am - 2:00 pm
5 Stars
Reviews on google
Years of Experience
Patients Treated
Smile Design Cases
Specializing In
High Anxiety Patient Comfort

Top Dentists in Southern Indiana

Sartini Dentistry, is committed to providing a safe, anxiety-free environment for everyone who steps through our doors. We are currently serving patients within a 50+ mile radius. We will listen, address all your dental fears, and help you achieve the smile of your dreams. It is very important to us that you feel at home here. We do all we can to make you feel comfortable, from blankets and headsets to video glasses, pain free numbing and upon request, oral conscious sedation. If you want a caring, highly trained, progressive dental experience you can call your dental home, then Sartini Dentistry is here for you.

Our Mission Statement

To Serve Our Team and Others with a Grateful Heart

Before and After

Use the slider below to see how much we can improve a smile




What Our Clients Are Saying

Dr. Sartini is the BEST! She is so kind and really takes her time to make sure her patients are at ease throughout whatever procedure they’re having completed. Not to mention, her work is beautiful! Her assistant Lauren is amazing as well. I drive 1.5 hours just to see her because no one else can do what she can!

-Lauren B
see more
Expert Care

Meet Our Dentists

Dr. Toni Sartini

I promise to make your visit as easy as possible and to give you the best dental care I can. I’ve been a dentist since 1986, and still LOVE my job. I feel very blessed to share my gifts and talents with my patients and my amazing, highly trained team.

Dr. Payton Schilling

Dr. Payton Schilling has been practicing alongside Dr. Sartini for two years and absolutely loves being a part of the Palmyra community. Her favorite part of working at Sartini Dentistry is the wonderful environment.

Members Of

Expert Care

The Best Choice in Dental Care.

At our practice, we strive to make your visit as comfortable, relaxing, and rewarding as possible by delivering patient-focused, personalized care.

General & Family Dentistry

Children’s Dentistry, Senior Dentistry, Tooth Extractions, Oral Cancer Screening


Gum and Bone Health, Deep Cleaning, Implant Maintenance, ARESTIN® Antibiotic Gum Treatment


Oral-Conscious Sedation
Prescription Strength Numbing Agent, Noise-Reduction Headphones, Warm Blankets Provided


BOTOX®, Teeth Whitening,
Smile Makeovers, & More


Metal-Free Fillings, Oral Cancer Screenings, & More


Bridges, Crowns, Implants, & More


Need Financing?

Payment is typically expected at the time of service. We accept most dental insurance plans as well as major credit cards, such as Discover, MC & Visa. For those that have extensive dental treatment we are pleased to accept CareCredit® to help our patients finance their treatment. This is a health based credit card that allows patients to pay for their services.

Learn more

Join Our Community